BILLBOARD News Now
Save America Act Backfire
(Editor’s note: The Wall Street Journal Review & Outlook today expressed an opinion about the Save America Act. It is being shared so you can form an opinion.)
President Trump broke into prime-time TV on Thursday night to talk to the nation about election security, but it must have been a letdown for anybody expecting a thrilling plot twist in Mr. Trump’s long yarn about his 2020 defeat. Instead he made a sales pitch for a bill that can’t pass, using doubts it wouldn’t address.
Mr. Trump released documents that he said show vulnerabilities in U.S. election systems, and some of them are real, though they run the gamut. He said voter files on millions of people, including names, addressees and party affiliations, “have been bought, stolen or hacked by China.” A 2020 intelligence memo advised that adversaries “have the capability to compromise” election infrastructure, especially “registration databases, pollbooks, and official election websites.”
But since Mr. Trump declassified the memo, we can quote the part he didn’t. “Vote tabulation systems would be difficult to manipulate on a wide enough scale to compromise election results,” it says. “The systems in each voting location are not connected to the Internet or to each other, and many methods for exploiting them rely on physical proximity.” Achieving it across many jurisdictions “would be difficult” and “audits and paper trails very likely would uncover such an effort.”
Mr. Trump went on to say that CIA reporting indicates Venezuela’s dictatorship conspired to rig its own election and “digitally alter vote totals.” He presented this as proof of concept that such a thing is possible. Sorry, the state of Georgia, which Mr. Trump lost in 2020 and then won in 2024, isn’t Venezuela, and Secretary of State Brad Raffensperger isn’t Nicolás Maduro.
Other files involve a drive for voter registration in Michigan. Mr. Trump alleged that some canvassers in 2020, who received gift cards based on productivity, “submitted fraudulent registration for people who did not exist.” If that’s true, law enforcement ought to pursue it. Yet how many registration forms? Were they accepted? Did any phantom people actually get a ballot? Mr. Trump didn’t say.
Then he urged passage of the SAVE America Act. “The only reason you wouldn’t do it is you want to cheat,” he said. “This landmark bill requires that all voters must show photo voter ID. How simple is that?” He also called to ban mail ballots, “except for illness, disability, military deployment or travel.”
The public likes voter ID, with a poll last year finding 83% of adults, and 71% of Democrats, favor it. Yet the SAVE America Act goes further, rendering most driver’s licenses insufficient to register to vote, and that’s to say nothing of Mr. Trump’s push to override laws in many GOP states—Florida, Georgia, most of the Midwest—that offer mail ballots for convenience.
In a floor speech Thursday, North Carolina Sen. Thom Tillis argued that even if Congress whooped through the bill, there isn’t time to implement it before November. By his reckoning, the U.S. has about 10,000 county clerks or municipal entities that carry out America’s decentralized elections. The midterms are barely 100 days away, early voting sooner. “The math doesn’t work,” he said. “It can’t be done.”
Mr. Tillis isn’t against ID rules, and he helped pass North Carolina’s. “We should figure out a way to get every state to get to voter ID,” he said. Yet he was unsparing toward Congress’s proponents of the SAVE America Act. “Mr. President, these people are misleading you if they’re telling you that this can be implemented by November,” he said. “This seems like a legit proposal, but it isn’t.”
Unfortunately, the message from Mr. Trump and others has been that America’s elections can’t be trusted, and the only hope is the SAVE America Act. Aside from being untrue, this is a political backfire for the GOP. If Republican voters believe it, and the bill falls short, then why waste time going to the polls in November? Has the GOP already forgotten how Mr. Trump’s fraud outbursts cost them two Senate seats in the 2021 Georgia runoffs?
Republicans should be campaigning on what they want to do with two more years in power. There are ways to improve voting integrity, but Mr. Tillis is right that it’s reckless to sow generalized suspicion that American elections aren’t honest. In fact, the intel memo Mr. Trump declassified warned this is what a U.S. adversary might do. “Much of the voting public probably knows little about the process of administering US elections,” it says, “which could allow false narratives to gain traction.”
That’s dated Jan. 15, 2020. Now there’s some prescient intelligence.
Use icons and envelope above to forward this post to your friends.
Follow us on Twitter (X), Bluesky, Instagram, Facebook or Threads.
Washington Insight
During my twenty-five years in Washington I worked in both the Congress and Executive branch. Though I pay attention to what goes on in Washington little did I realize since coming home in 1993 how much both have changed. Doing my morning reading I found two...
Political Tidbits…5.17.13
Quiet time for politics seem to end this week…WV House Speaker Thompson resigned…Obama sandals get noisy…the media is looking for a new Watergate [if your old enough to recall it]…some young hungry reporters have visions of being the next Woodward & Bernstein [key...
Required Reading for Republicans
We were present for the Reagan Revolution. Jenny and I served in the presidency of Ronald Reagan. Often over dinner we recall the Reagan approach to government and issues. Likewise, we discuss that the “conservatives” in today’s world must engage in redefining the...
How Manchin Did It!
After Senator Manchin’s announcement that he had reached a deal on background checks in the gun control debate yesterday several people I spoke with asked how he did it. The answer came this morning when The Charleston Daily Mail ran an article that appeared in The...
Rural Fight Ahead?
Small States The significance of small states is the subject of a lengthy article in The New York Times. The focus is on their growing importance in the U.S. Senate. Throughout the article you can feel the message of unfairness to urban America. When a publication...
Republican Bank Is Open
Republican activists should be aware the State Party is now paying for mailings and phone calls for candidates in non-partisan elections. Just open these links and see for yourself. https://phillipsbillboard.com/media/photo1.JPG...
Political Tidbits…2.28.13
February is the month the groundhog appears…well guess it’s time for PHILLIPSBILLBOARD…to show up before the month is out…seems political news has been slow during hibernation. What has really been slow is a significant Democrat to emerge for the U.S. Senate seat …now...
Manchin Continues
Senator Joe Manchin continues his “campaign” of attracting national media attention. This morning’s New York Times features him front page with a color picture. A NYT reporter joined Senator Manchin in Beckley where he brought 15 citizens together for a discussion...
Historic Change
Inaugurations present new opportunities and expectations. As I sat watching Governor Earl Ray Tomblin take the oath of office for the third time I thought about that day 17 years ago when Governor Cecil H. Underwood took that same oath for the second time. There is a...
Political Tidbits…1.6.13
POLITICAL TIDBITS as we ended the first week of 2013. Another Republican…House GOP Leader Tim Armstead understands the importance of working with Democrats…he recently told the Register-Herald in Beckley…"We’ve already had discussions with Democratic members about...
In & Out
As we enter 2013 it’s fun to think about what is In & Out. Here is my list of 13. In Out RGIII Romo No WV...
EPA Jackson’s Email Scandal
My recollection is President Obama promised the American people the “most transparent government ever.” How could I have missed this story? While West Virginia coal miners are providing an honest day’s work to provide the energy that fuels the Internet, EPA...
BILLBOARD Archives
Is It Good News?
[Editor’s Note: Guest commentary is welcome on PHILLIPSBILLBOARD. Bob Harris grew up in Charleston, WV and sent the piece below following our post about the EPA Administrator’s planned departure. Harris is based in Washington with extensive Capitol Hill experience....
EPA Chief Gone
News just broke that Lisa Jackson EPA Chief will leave the Obama administration. Is that good news for West Virginia? Who knows as I learned long ago be careful what you ask for! Here is the NY Times story.
Tipping Point
Last week WV Senator Joe Manchin made news across the country with his comments related to guns. His action and words have caused a stir. President Obama gave him a call and over 100 protesters on a Saturday before Christmas showed up at this office. The Outlook...
Wrap-Up
After you finish wrapping your Christmas gifts check out the giving and receiving to political candidate this year. Below you will find the information filed to cover October 22 until November 18. Click on a name to open. Governor Bill Maloney Earl Ray Tomblin...
Outrageous
(Editor’s Note: I served in the US Department of Agriculture as Director of the Office of Rural Development Policy. Likewise, worked for Members of Congress who served on House of Representatives Agriculture Committee and the Public Works Committee that handled...
Big Tent
Big Tent My friend the late Lee Atwater [ran Bush 41 campaign & served at Republican National Chairman] coined the phrase “big tent” to the best of my recollection. My friend Jim Lees [twice Democratic candidate for Governor] had an Op Ed in today’s Charleston...
Capito Hurt?
There has been a political development on the national stage that could impact Rep. Shelley Moore Capito’s announced plans to seek the U. S. Senate in 2014. Only time will tell. Today U. S. Senator Jim DeMint (R-S.C.) well known for his recent efforts to recruit the...
Political Tidbits…12.4.12
BIG DAY...yesterday for Republicans as 11 new House of Delegates members was sworn in...not to be overlooked are the returning GOP House & Senate members or the growth of the GOP. Don't look for an extravaganza when Gov. Tomblin is sworn into office in...
Congressional Shopping
A new item has been added to the holiday shopping list in West Virginia’s second congressional district – a Member of Congress. What about a centrist who was defeated for GOP National Committeeman for knowing how to work with Democrats? I am a fiscal conservative and...
Advice
After the not-so-surprising announcement that Congresswoman Shelley Moore Capito will become a candidate for the United States Senate the attention among these West Virginia hills is the “fiscal cliff." Its impact could result in significant change in our State that...
Conspiracy
(Disclosure: My wife is one of the WV State Board of Education who resigned earlier this week. The views below are mine alone. I would never attempt to speak for her.) This week a despicable and senseless action was taken at the WV State School Board meeting. A...
Aftermath Part II
The morning afterwards I wrote a piece about the Aftermath. I mentioned if there a lesson to be learned from the positive campaign [my wife Jenny’s thought] of Allen Loughry approach in winning a seat on the Supreme Court. There is a front page story about this very...