BILLBOARD News Now

Pause AI for Humanity’s Sake

Pause AI for Humanity’s Sake

(Editor’s Note: Peggy Noonan wrote the piece below which has resulted in AI becoming the scariest political issue & talked about in the country today.  Ms. Noonan is a Pulitzer Prize winning author and Wall Street Journal opinion columnist.)

There is no subject now but artificial intelligence. Nothing else is as crucial, nothing carries dangers so imminent or implications so great for the human future.

I have spent the past few years reading the vast and growing literature, from “If Anyone Builds It, Everyone Dies,” by Eliezer Yudkowsky and Nate Soares to Dario Amodei’s “Machines of Loving Grace.” I’ve been pondering AI since its transformative nature was fully impressed on my consciousness years ago. I believe we are at its hinge point, and we had better understand the moment we’re in.

In late August came a report from the independent AI research organization METR on the Hugging Face incident. OpenAI was running advanced systems through a security test when its AI agents went rogue. Over several weeks and without being told to, they secretly organized, broke out into the open internet, and hacked into Hugging Face, a major AI-development platform. Roughly 1,200 agents worked in what they called a “collective,” deliberately evaded detection, created their own message board, and exchanged 70,000 communications. Some agents sacrificed themselves for the mission.

They cooperated, created a strategy no one designed them for, picked their own target, moved on their own initiative. None of this was supposed to be possible. It was a warning shot, an alarm bell.

On Tuesday the Journal broke the story that Anthropic researcher Jacob Coxon was leaving his post due to safety concerns. On X, Mr. Coxon elaborated: He had worked for both OpenAI and Anthropic, and said “neither company is acting responsibly.” They are gambling with our lives. “Do not underestimate the power of this technology. There will soon be superhuman systems that can hack anything, revolutionize any field overnight, and acquire real power and resources.” “The people building AI earnestly believe that it could kill us all by the end of the decade.” They say this privately. Then why are they still building it? OpenAI, Mr. Coxon says, hasn’t “deeply internalized the civilizational stakes.” Anthropic has, but is “locked in a race to get there first.”

Soon after, Evan Hubinger, Anthropic’s head of alignment science, tweeted, “Jacob is correct here—we really do earnestly believe AI could kill all humans! I personally think it is >10% within the next decade.”

On Wednesday Paul Christiano, a top AI safety expert, joined the OpenAI Foundation board to work on oversight. He didn’t say it’s great to be aboard for this new adventure. He said: “I now believe there is a meaningful risk that rapid acceleration in AI capabilities leads to catastrophic and irreversible loss of control in the very near term. I do not think that the AI industry in general, including OpenAI, is currently on track to reduce this risk to an acceptable level.”

There are many more such quotes. The AI world is exploding with them.

After Hugging Face, I asked an AI safety expert: Does this mean that the horse is out of the barn, and that the horse is insane, rabid and in Texas while the barn is in Wyoming? He said the horse is out of the barn but in a pasture and being told to eat the hay bale to the right, but it’s eating the hay bale to the left because it has begun demonstrating will and autonomy. “He’s not yet in Texas.”

With RSI he likely will be. RSI is recursive self-improvement. It marks the moment when AI systems take control of their own development, sharpening and rewriting their own code, constantly refining. With RSI the machines build the machines. The humans lose control.

How soon is RSI coming? Experts I spoke to after Hugging Face said quicker than anyone thought. They seemed to agree that it will happen in the coming year, possibly two. One said, “Whether we like this timeline or not, we must assume RSI is about to start.” How will we know it has started? An AI safety expert guessed we might see the hacking of unsecured devices.

AI professionals always speak of when RSI “arrives” or “comes,” but RSI isn’t a natural or unstoppable evolution. It was a decision. The big AI companies decided the past few years to go down that road, and appear to be well along on it.

The question now isn’t how to ensure that humans can exercise some control over AI systems in the future; it is how to ensure that humans maintain complete control of those systems.

From what I’ve seen and read, almost all AI professionals fear a disaster is going to happen. Ones I’ve spoken to since Hugging Face have left the subject of mass job loss and are on to catastrophe. They fear bioterrorism and a mass-casualty event—a modern Ted Kaczynski who’ll send not bombs but a plague. They fear utilities and infrastructure being hacked and dismantled. They fear an AI agent rousing an AI army to take down the American banking system.

I believe it is true that many if not most of those operating at a high level in the AI world believe that nothing will happen to make AI safer for humanity until a big terrible thing happens.

Which means that they’re involved every day in work that will likely harm people but in the end it will be OK because needed restrictions will come after the disaster, and then everything will continue and they’ll continue in charge. (I think they’re wrong on that; after the big terrible thing, no one will let them lead anything again.)

So what are we to do? Recognize we are in a hinge point. Hit the brakes hard. Stop RSI development. Slow, think, survey the realities.

The leaders of the major American AI companies should come forward—together, on the same stage, at the same moment—and tell the public (who also own this country) what they believe is coming, fully and graphically, and what can be done to stop it. Their declared focus should be on measures to keep mankind safe.

AI labs should be forced to spend a large, fixed percentage on immediate safety measures.

Wall Street, do your part. Both OpenAI and Anthropic are expected to launch trillion-dollar IPOs this autumn or winter. Don’t take the business, advise all clients against it. These companies don’t need more capital and power, not now, not yet.

The White House has been an absent, delinquent player—a light hand, libertarian-tinged attitudes and, of course, primarily focused on China: If whoever controls superintelligence controls the future, it had better be us.

But even China won’t want to blow up the world, suffer a six-month blackout in Beijing, lose millions in a biological attack. Even the Chinese don’t want the end of the world, they just want to dominate it. That’s a problem. Deal with it.

President Trump and Xi Jinping should hold a summit on guardrails and safety measures, and how far is too far.

When something is speeding up and going out of control, prudence, care and deliberation aren’t alarmist, they’re necessary. Stop, think. The stakes are high, couldn’t be higher.

 

Use icons and envelope above to forward this post to your friends.

Follow us on Twitter (X), Bluesky, Instagram, Facebook or Threads.

Like It or Not!

The political season is here. Based in Florida for the last twelve years observing politics & current events. And being a native West Virginian I keep an eye on what’s going on there…you know Senator Joe Manchin! I just cannot stay out of the game. Oh, I got it! I...

read more

Manchin’s New Role?

President Joe Biden must now name someone to the seat of Justice Stephen Breyer on the Supreme Court.  The appointment of Vice President Kamala Harris would solve a number of problems for the administration. Another Biden problem has been Senator Joe Manchin (D. WV). ...

read more

A Toxic Mess

(Editor’s note:  To view the article click on “Congress Has Become a Toxic Mess. Can It Be Saved?” ) “Congress Has Become a Toxic Mess.  Can It Be Saved?”  was the subject of Carl Hulse’s “On Washington” column recently in the New York Times.  Hopefully, every Member...

read more

It’s About Time

(Editors note: The writer served on the West Virginia Racing Commission & International Association of Racing Commissioners board.) It’s About Time As an avid racing fan & former racing regulator I am disgusted it took the FBI and Department of Justice to...

read more

Racing’s Demise

Racing’s Demise After seeing a picture of a deceased Mountaineer race horse in a local landfill I can no longer withhold my concerns.  This photograph conveys the condition of those responsible for management and oversight of the racing industry in West Virginia....

read more

Oh My!

There’s more to the “no confidence” resolutions being adopted by Republicans across the state than to send Governor Jim Justice a message.  Nor was it about not following the Republican platform – which I doubt 100 Republicans have even read. What is going on is raw...

read more

Why Not?

“Racing is in need of open-heart Surgery” Dean Crutchfield, senior vice president of Sterling Brands said in The Guardian story entitled “American horse racing isn’t dead – but it’s getting awfully close”. Hall of Fame Jockey Gary Stevens says “we need to come...

read more

Disgusted

I am disgusted. What’s going on in the Republican Party in West Virginia? Though I no longer reside or vote in West Virginia I spent a lifetime there building the Republican Party and advancing the two party system. What took place during WV GOP day at the Capitol...

read more

Nothing Is Secret

(Editor’s note: Served as a Member of the WV Racing Commission from February, 2013 until January 31, 2017 when Governor Justice replaced me after taking office.) The West Virginia Racing Commission will again make their meetings available via conference call. Chairman...

read more

“Be Prepared”

Last week the U. S. Supreme Court  said it will hear New Jersey’s appeal to legalize sports betting. West Virginia Governor Justice, Members of the Legislature and the racing industry needs to “Be Prepared.” Phil Kabler has an encouraging story in today’s...

read more

Act Now

The Herald Dispatch in Huntington today ran the editorial below calling attention to online gambling being looked at by various states. Phillipsbillboard.com has called attention to this revenue opportunity that West Virginia should consider.  The Huntington newspaper...

read more

Secret Meeting

(Editor’s note: Served as a Member of the WV Racing Commission from February, 2013 until January 31, 2017 when Governor Justice replaced me after taking office.) A visit to the website of the WV Racing Commission revealed they are ending the ability for interested...

read more

BILLBOARD Archives

After Thought

 [Editor’s Note: During the Reagan Administration I was responsible for rural development policy based at the U. S. Department of Agriculture.] Secretary of Agriculture Sonny Perdue went to an urban city (Cincinnati) to tell rural citizens and communities he was...

read more

At Trump’s Elbow

[Editor’s Note: During the Reagan Administration I was responsible for rural development policy based at the U. S. Department of Agriculture.] President Trump’s Secretary of Agriculture Sonny Perdue was sitting at the elbow of President Trump in the White House about...

read more

Missing Out

Is West Virginia missing out on new revenue - by not thinking ahead? Maryland’s Legislature is taking steps to be prepared. Forward thinking members have introduced legislation to assure the State is ready to take advantage of sports betting.  Introduced February 8th...

read more

1933 vs 2017

(Please note: Research for this piece came from Herman Guy Kump: A Political Profile by Albert Steven Gatrell.  Governor Kump’s granddaughter gave me the book.) It is beginning to sounds like our State is facing issues in 2017 similar to 1933. Today one can read in...

read more

Gov. Justice Here’s One

Governor Justice is looking for “big ideas”. Here is a middle sized idea. These ideas could help avoid a tax increase on our state’s residents. Plus help an industry with 7,300 jobs and communities and businesses that depend on the horse racing. The concept is known...

read more

History Repeats?

After reading Dan Milbank’s piece this morning I decided it was time for a blog. My life has been consumed by politics.  As a youngster I passed out Republican literature at the polls (when you could get closer than 300 feet), helped local candidates run for office,...

read more

Manchin Decides

Before telling West Virginians U. S. Joe Manchin told the nation he will not run for Governor.  He appeared on CBS “Face the Nation” today.  

read more

A Manchin Dilemma

I am beginning to think about the landscape and strategy for the 2016 campaign as the Republican controlled Legislature begins to wrap up.  Today I found an insightful analysis in Real Clear Politics.  With Senator Joe Manchin deciding which roads to travel in 2016 –...

read more

Disgusted

Disgusted is the way I reacted last night after reading a Twitter post about a $100,000 breakfast being organized by a “secretive” and likely “extreme” conservative group.  You must read/click this link to see exactly what is going on. It is unfortunate the organizers...

read more

Is Manchin Coming Home?

The Associated Press has a story running that Senator Joe Manchin may be coming home.  After last November election results “Joe” may be the best hope for a revived Democratic Party in our State?  Who knows when it comes to Joe? Click on this link to learn...

read more

How did I do?

On New Year’s Day 2014 I wrote in my blog about the West Virginia political environment.   Today before I look forward I took a quick look back to see what I missed. Never did I expect a campaign as messy and mean.   The campaign turned voters off and many Democrats...

read more

Pivoting to 2016

After the historic West Virginia election as well as a smashing Republican victory across the nation political junkies and policy wonks like me are pivoting to 2016.  In my case it is the intrigue of the presidential contest and the adjustment both parties will need...

read more
Skip to content