BILLBOARD News Now
Art of the Self-Deal
(Editor’s note: Peggy Noonan is one of America’s most respected writers & columnist at the Wall Street Journal. Today her column “Declarations” provides thoughts on how Trump-era corruption is affecting Americans as a people.)
I’m thinking about the deeper effects of governmental corruption in the Trump era, and why it leaves many not only indignant but uneasy. I suspect it’s doing something to us as a people. The thoughts were prompted by a poll this week from Reuters/Ipsos, which Reuters headlined “Most Americans Believe Trump Has Inappropriately Profited Since Returning to Power.” It reported that 69% of respondents see his personal business interests as influencing presidential decisions. Two-thirds of independents, half of Republicans and 9 in 10 Democrats shared that view.
Republicans, God bless them, were split on whether graft under Mr. Trump has gotten worse or better or stayed the same, which makes that polling question a case study in how bright people are capable of not seeing what they don’t want to see.
We’ll quickly posit what we mean by Trump-era corruption. I see two general areas, personal enrichment and the use of government to satisfy private goals.
The personal-enrichment part is suggested by recent and frequent reports showing that Mr. Trump’s net worth, and that of his family, has surged dramatically in his second term. This isn’t just wealthy folks seeing their stocks go up: Trump businesses have developed positions in industries over which the administration exercises power.
Some were in cryptocurrency, and there is the $Trump meme coin, some of the largest buyers of which have been given access to the president, some at a dinner at one of his golf clubs. A Washington Post analysis suggests roughly half may be foreign-based. The Journal has reported that representatives of Sheikh Tahnoun bin Zayed Al Nahyan of Abu Dhabi agreed to purchase 49% of a Trump crypto entity for $500 million. Sheikh Tahnoun is not only a businessman but a senior member of the United Arab Emirates’ ruling family and its national-security adviser. This newspaper also reports that Mr. Trump made many millions licensing his name to overseas property developers, including developers in Qatar, Saudi Arabia, the U.A.E. and Oman.
These are items in a longer possible list, but are representative of the administration’s general approach. The size and means of this enrichment would seem . . . dubious? Careless of appearances? Appalling?
As to the use of governmental power to achieve not public but personal goals, including revenge and punishing enemies, there have been numerous reports—it feels like a new one every day—of bending, testing or getting around the law to make the administration’s friends happy and enemies sad. This has included paying people in Mr. Trump’s orbit to lobby for presidential pardons—this newspaper has done great work there—launching strange investigations, and muscling law firms and media companies.
Republicans seem generally not to have found the last alarming, which is alarming. You don’t like Jimmy Kimmel? I don’t like Jimmy Kimmel; he’s boorish, crude, tinnily self-valorizing. But defending speech when it’s muscled by government? Yes, of course. Governments are worse than networks because the former have the power to crush you, and you only get one at a time, and you can’t change the channel except every four years. Be on the side of the information flow, even when it’s full of sludge. Be on the side of the voice, not the big crushing thing. Conservatives used to know to fear government, and beat it back.
An odd thing about all this is the absence of furor. There is no broad public outcry. Why? Because corruption is a constant and “the other side is dirty too.” Because the scandal threshold has skyrocketed. President Trump walked into history dragging a long tail of litigation, accusation and lawsuits behind him. He never sold himself as a man of moral rectitude, and most supporters didn’t think that’s what they were buying. Jimmy Carter’s shaking down the system to see what coins fall out would have been news, Donald Trump’s doing the same is Tuesday.
And there’s the sheer scale: The extraordinary becomes ordinary through repetition; scandals add up and become a blur, not a call to action. But the country pays a cost for all this. Institutionally, everything happening today sets a precedent. Every abuse we accept widens the range of possible misbehavior for the next administration.
Corruption is more dangerous, has a more deteriorating effect, than bad policy. Bad policy can be reversed. Corruption works its way into a system and changes its nature.
Suppose a Republican president leaves office having established that a president can use regulatory powers against antagonistic institutions, exert pressures on companies needing government approval, and demand personal loyalty throughout the executive branch, all with no lasting repercussions. The next administration, disposed in other ideological directions, inherits the precedents. It says turnabout is fair play.
An Ocasio-Cortez administration wouldn’t have meme coins and golf resorts, it would look much cleaner! Progressives usually aren’t set on personal cash, they’re set on institutional power. They would privately thank Mr. Trump for proving restraints on executive power are weaker than previously thought, and publicly claim that finally we have a president who advances the public interest.
But I suppose the larger threat of governmental corruption is that it hurts the public’s morale, its sense of seeing itself as a moral actor to whom politicians have to answer. Our entire system of government assumes a citizenry that polices its politicians, that says “You can’t do that, this office isn’t yours, your powers were lent to you for public purposes.” If the public shrugs and looks away, Americans will lose the habit of thinking of themselves as entitled to a clean government. And they’ll have to admit they surrendered their own views to the views of the tribe.
It is the public’s role to uphold republican standards. In the past, a politician caught selling an office, taking money from interested parties, using governmental machinery for personal revenge was supposed to fear not only legal action but disgrace.
Citizens derive a certain dignity from believing that we enforce the rules. It reminds them who’s in charge: them. You’re giving up a lot when you give that up.
In times of corruption, good people who might run for office, don’t. They think they can’t survive in that world. Bad people, those with limited internal ethical and moral structures, are encouraged: Politics is a way to get rich and famous, to push people around. They are elected, govern badly, corruptly, and the cycle continues.
Unchecked corruption tells cynics not that they have an uninteresting flaw but that they are realists. Never tell cynics that. It gives them license.
As always, the whole world is watching. What it has seen lowers the esteem in which it formally (if grudgingly) held Americans. It embarrasses us before the world. It hurts our heart a little. We were the morally rectitudinous Doughboy GI Marshall Planning JFK and Ronnie People who made the wall come down. We did our best each generation to be equal to our reputation, or at least to have some class. There are foreign policy implications to all this. Some day we’ll need friends and see only the satisfied spite of the previously jealous.
Nothing good comes from this. When corruption is allowed, it governs not today but tomorrow too.
Use icons and envelope above to forward this post to your friends.
Follow us on Twitter (X), Bluesky, Instagram, Facebook or Threads.
Aftermath
Today is a new day in the political world. Yesterday brought cheers to some and extreme disappointment to many. What happen and why, what needs done? We all know what happen. On the surface without much sleep or study it appears the Obama team after 2008 made a...
Good Morning
Many of PHILLIPSBILLBOARD readers not living in the “political valley” may enjoy reading a wrap-up piece on this Election Day. It appeared in this morning’s Charleston Daily Mail written by Ry Rivard Mail Capitol Reporter. It you do Twitter he is worth following...
Political Tidbits…Day Before
Taking a last look at the 2012 campaign reveals little…you hardly know there is a statewide election…expect by seeing the lines at early voting places…Governor Tomblin had to deal with a lady named Sandy…candidate Maloney put his last dollars into a newspaper ad aimed...
Sandy
You can bet Sandy would not win any election but all interest is focused on her. However, Political Junkies like me and a lot of you are wondering what impact she will have and where does things stand as the snow begins to fall. The immediate impact is likely to be...
Mother’s Milk
There is an old expression “money is the mother’s milk of politics.” WV candidates are filing their last report before the November 6th election. PHILLIPSBILLBOARD provides readers an easy way to see where the money comes from and where it goes. Listed below are...
Political Tidbits…10.26.12
A few Tidbits for your weekend…not that you have not had enough politics…let’s hope it is over in 11 days…but with the presidential race so tight… This makes me wonder…are Republicans concerned this could end up in the House of Representatives…this might explain the...
Books
Books elect presidents not a slick pamphlet laid out like a magazine. The Obama campaign’s release of this last minute brochure makes him look a candidate running for almost any office on a shoe string budget. Obama’s brochure has 20 pages covering manufacturing,...
Fatigue
Voters start to the polls today. They have faced six elections starting in 2010. Voters are suffering election fatigue, the candidates are running tried campaigns and the money providers are drained. Campaigns need energy to be successful. The Governor’s race in WV...
Political Valley
As you can see there is a divide in the way the newspapers in “political valley” look at various races. The WV Press Association has pushed this week as Endorsement Week. As a result it is easier for voters to compare the opinions of newspaper editorial boards. ...
Update
Political news and endorsements have increased this week. I will share a few to assist readers who are not in the “political valley” keep up. Click on the headline to read full story. U. S. Senate W.Va. needs to change the Senate; Republican John Raese would The...
Bob’s View
[Editor’s Note: After the last presidential debate I got an email from Bob Harris a longtime friend. He provided me his views about the debate and Obama’s inability to use the tools of his position. Bob is an astute observer of Washington, the national political...
Political Tidbits…10.12.12
TAKE AWAYS from last night’s VP debate…Biden has been watching too many Gore re-runs from 2000 debate…and they should never have put Red Bull in his holding room…both bases won…Obama is going to Williamsburg for three days…debate prep or American history lesson?...
BILLBOARD Archives
Your Decision
[Editor’s Explanation: I quickly learned reviewing the daily newspapers across the state was overwhelming in my quest to provide statewide political news. I appreciate the response from those outside the “political valley” and will work to provide coverage of...
Day & Night
Yesterday was a big day in WV 2012 election. Gubernatorial candidates faced off at The Charleston Daily Mail and US Senate candidates went at it in Eastern WV. Here are a few clips to give you a quick update on WV political developments. Tonight all eyes will be on...
Staying Updated
Below is a collection of news from around the State. You can read the full story you find of interest. Just click on the headline. Continuity VS. Change By Phil Kabler [Staff writer, The Charleston Gazette] Gov. Earl Ray Tomblin made his case for re-election to a...
Political Tidbits…10.2.12
A kick in the…that is what I got from readers…wanting more news…hope you saw the first Blog News…a Mountain State collection…at least for the next 35 days. Talk about too much going on…candidates financial reports posted as Big Four Money…well here is the second...
Full Swing
Blog News 9.29.12 This is PhillipsBillBoard first Blog News posting. This has been a busy week for political news. Thanks for sending me your ideas. Below is a collection from around the State. You can read the full story of those you find of interest. Just...
Big Four
Big Money Races There appears to be little interest in 2012 November election. However, there is always interest in money. Three statewide races are drawing attention. Today was the deadline for candidates to file finance reports. Take a close look. Just click on...
Careful
Recently I have been out and about at various events and places. Often I am hearing “your blog is the only way I know what is going on in politics”. Followed by why are you not publishing? Let me explain. Since I am active in politics (Republican) or have a lot of...
Again
Again WV candidates are at the post. Ry Rivard [Capitol Reporter for Daily Mail] has provided a snapshot of the political races just as the gate opens on these horse races. Many PhillipsBillBoard readers and political junkies may not see his Charleston Daily Mail...
Political Tidbits…9.1.12
TAMPA….in the early morning hours of yesterday most WV delegates to the Republican National Convention started for home….fired up about Mitt Romney as the country’s next President….but a little less unified as a State Republican Party than when they arrived. The big...
Upcoming
Many of us will recall when we watched every national political convention development (Democrat and Republican) on television. With the national conventions just days away if you want to know what is really taking place you had better tune in to social media. An...
A Day
A day is a year in politics the old saying goes. In a post just yesterday I made note that I thought dropping Biden and putting Hillary on the ticket would be a game changer in West Virginia. Today (thanks to a tip from my friend Tom O’Neill) I learned the Weekly...
Today’s Politics
It’s a cloudy morning in Elkins so I took a glance at various political newsletters and clipped some of the most interesting. My thanks to POLITICO, Daily Callers, Fox News, Huff Post & NY Times. THE CAMPAIGN REACHED A NEW LOW YESTERDAY- BIDEN in Danville, Va.:...